The Safest Caribbean Islands
By crime and hurricane risk
The Safest Caribbean Islands
These are some of the top 5 safest Caribbean Islands, taking their crime rate and risk of natural disaster into consideration.
- Aruba
- Montserrat
- Saint Barthélemy
- Grenada
- Barbados
Aruba
What makes Aruba so safe?
Aruba very rarely experiences natural disasters like hurricanes or bad storms, because it's slightly south of the hurricane belt. This means that you can travel to Aruba even during the Caribbean hurricane season (June to November), and you most likely won't be impacted by a hurricane. In fact, there's usually only one hurricane in Aruba every 28 years!
Aruba has a crime index of 30.81, which gives it a low level of crime. Things like violent crime are rare, and reports show a very high level of safety during the day and a high level at night.
Are there any risks to Aruba?
Although Aruba has both a low risk of crime and natural disaster, as with anywhere, instances can still occur. Petty theft does happen, so ensure you keep your belongings close to you, and there will occasionally be a bad storm.
Adhere to standard safety advice, such as keeping your wits about you, being respectful, and avoiding dark, isolated areas when alone.
Montserrat
What makes Montserrat so safe?
Montserrat has a very low crime rate, with a crime index of just 12.25. To put this into perspective, London's crime index is 55.46. The lower the score, the lower your chance of falling victim to a crime.
Results also show a low level of crime at night, meaning you'll be safe to walk around the island no matter the time of day. There are also low levels of gender, racial or sexuality-based discrimination.
Are there any risks to Montserrat?
While Montserrat's crime rate is exceptionally low, there are other things to consider. Montserrat is prone to natural disasters, specifically volcanic eruptions and hurricanes, which have been fatal.
Hurricane season in Montserrat starts in early June and ends late November, so if you want to lower your chances of being impacted by a hurricane, it's best to avoid these times. While volcanoes aren't tied to a specific time of the year, upcoming eruptions can be detected days, weeks, or even years in advance, meaning you'll have plenty of time to evacuate if an eruption were to occur.
Saint Barthélemy
What makes St. Barts so safe?
Saint Barts is one of the safest Caribbean Islands thanks to its very low crime rate, especially when it comes to violent crime. The most common type of criminal activity in Saint Barts (although still extremely low) is petty theft.
You'll be safe exploring Saint Barts, day or night. However, it's recommended to keep expensive possessions, such as jewellery, out of sight at night to further ensure you're not targeted by thieves.
Are there any risks to St. Barts?
Saint Barts does experience natural disasters, such as hurricanes and floods. Hurricane season runs from June to November, which can lead to severe flooding, so it's best to avoid these periods.
Grenada
What makes Grenada so safe?
Grenada has a low-crime index of just 19.38. While there's been a slight rise in crime in the last 5 years, it remains one of the safest Caribbean Islands.
People report feeling very safe in Grenada, day or night, regardless of gender, making it an excellent destination for solo female travellers.
Are there any risks to Grenada?
Grenada experiences natural disasters like hurricanes and tropical storms. Most of its storms and hurricanes occur between August and September.
Barbados
What makes Barbados so safe?
Barbados is located on the edge of the hurricane belt, meaning it's much less susceptible to hurricanes as well as other natural disasters caused by hurricanes, such as flooding and landslides. Barbados also has a low level of violent crime.
Are there any risks to Barbados?
While Barbados' violent crime score is low, its general level of crime is higher than the other islands on this list. It has a crime index of 44.68, which is considered a moderate level of crime. There has been an increase in crime over the last few years, particularly with theft-related offences.
Barbados has a moderate score for safety when it comes to walking at night, meaning it's in your best interest to stick to populated, well-lit areas if you're out after sunset.
What are the least safe Caribbean Islands?
The least safe Caribbean Islands have higher levels of crime and an increased risk of fatal natural disasters. For many of these locations, only specific parts of the island may be unsafe, so if you plan on going to any of these destinations, make sure to do plenty of research.
Highest levels of crime:
- Haiti - High: 77.9
- Trinidad And Tobago - High: 70.8
- Jamaica - High: 68.1
- US Virgin Islands - High: 62.1
- Puerto Rico - High: 61.7
Highest hurricane risk:
- The Bahamas
- Antigua and Barbuda
- The British Virgin Islands
How to stay safe in the Caribbean Islands?
Avoid dark, isolated areas
While many of the safest locations listed on this page have high levels of safety at night, you're still going to want to be cautious about isolated areas. Wherever you go, crimes can still occur, and opportunists are more likely to target someone who's entirely alone.
Stay in contact with loved ones
By staying in contact with friends and family, such as sending them a quick message each day, they'll know you're safe. That way, if they suddenly stop hearing from you, they'll know something's wrong and will be able to alert authorities.
Keep valuables hidden
To avoid falling victim to theft, keep expensive valuables out of sight. Avoid wearing flashy jewellery at night and keep your phone in your bag. Don't leave items unattended, such as at the beach. Many hotels will have safes and lockers, which are great for keeping items that you really don't want to lose, like your passport or sentimental belongings.
Know the local laws
Depending on where you're going, the laws may be different to what you're used to. For example, some of the islands have weed consumption as a criminal offence. There are also quite a few Caribbean Islands that criminalise homosexuality, including Grenada and Barbados. While punishments can vary, it's essential to know the laws of each country to avoid unknowingly putting yourself at risk of detention.
Trusted globally
Rated Excellent on Trustpilot
We’re super proud of our Trustpilot rating, but don’t just take it from us. See why millions of others love booking their flights through Alternative Airlines
Safest Caribbean Islands FAQs
What are the safest Caribbean Islands?
Some of the safest Caribbean Islands include Aruba, Montserrat, Saint Barthélemy, Grenada and Barbados. These islands all have low crime rates or hurricane risks.
Which Caribbean Islands are safest from hurricanes?
As most of the Caribbean is part of the hurricane belt, there's a higher risk of hurricanes than in other parts of the world. However, there are still islands which rarely experience hurricanes. These include the ABC Islands, which are Aruba, Bonaire and Curaçao.
Which Caribbean Islands are the safest for LGBTQ+ travellers?
Many of the Caribbean Islands are very welcoming towards LGBTQ+ travellers, particularly Aruba, Puerto Rico and Curaçao. These islands have many gay bars as well as anti-discrimination laws to protect citizens and visitors.
Which Caribbean Island are the safest for solo female travellers?
Generally, the lower a country's level of crime, the higher its safety for solo female travellers. Places on this list, like Aruba and Montserrat, are great for solo female travellers.
Are vaccinations needed for the Caribbean Islands?
WHO recommends that tourists going to the Caribbean Islands get vaccinations for the following hepatitis A, hepatitis B, typhoid, cholera, yellow fever and rabies.